Yesterday I made the mistake of putting my head above the parapet in the matter of the Green Party’s response to the Israel/Palestine issue. My first mistake was to think that people would assume my views on the issue to be promoting peace, love and universal harmony. I’m not going to go into detail of what exactly was said, suffice to say I advised a Green Party member to check the GPEW national approach to the conflict in Gaza before issuing a statement, to ensure that the statement represented the subtleties and complexities of the party’s opinion. The response to this essentially accused me of sitting on the fence on the issue, and of supporting the “Israeli military machine”.
Considering that at no point had I given any personal opinion on the issue, simply a piece of advice, I find this, not insulting, but certainly annoying. Annoying, because it demonstrates that the knee-jerk reflexes and lack of rational, reasoned analysis of the conflict, and its long-term implications on the region extends into the Green Party.
The debate on Israel and Palestine needs to be removed from this hot-headed approach, and considered properly and calmly. Any resolution to the present conflict must either set the stage for the development of a long term programme for peace, or be that very programme.
Conflicts in Israel and Palestine will continue so long as inequalities and discrimination continue. A peaceful resolution can only be achieved if both sides in this conflict (and I show no preference for Israel or Palestine here) lay down their arms and realise that they are all people. They have the same needs: food, water, shelter, social contact. Yes, they practice their religion in different ways, but that is no excuse whatsoever for the divisions in Israeli/Palestinian society.
The essential point I wish to convey with this post, is that I think there is a need to step back for a moment and make reasoned consideration of the full complexities of the conflict, and what can be done to resolve it and provide a sustainable peace. Accusations flying around help no-one, least of all those suffering in Gaza and Israel.
I support peaceful, non-violent protests to call for an end to conflict on both sides. What I don’t support are protests or actions which take sides with either the Israeli government, or the Palestinian Hamas government. Now is the time to bring peace for everyone living in Israel and Palestine, not peace for some, and punishment for others.
Comments are moderated on this post. My blog, my rules.